Careful! Keep your guard up!

November 9, 2012

Karin Goyer Don S. Shoemaker Forgeries, Copies & Attributions , Leave a comment


Beware of this new attribution as just found by many of my readers (sorry for the delay of response to all of you, but I am currently far from Paris) at a Vintage Furniture Fair in Mexico City:

Copyright © 2010 – 2017 Karin Goyer. All Rights Reserved.

@donshoemaker.com

W A R N I N G !!!

November 8, 2011

Karin Goyer Don S. Shoemaker Forgeries, Copies & Attributions , 2 Comments


Beware of these Don S. Shoemaker attributions:

Copyright © 2010-2017 Karin Goyer. All Rights Reserved.

@donshoemaker.com

The palo fierro dominoes sets from the Seri natives

April 26, 2011

Karin Goyer Don S. Shoemaker Accessories, Game Sets & Boxes, Don S. Shoemaker Forgeries, Copies & Attributions , , , , Leave a comment


Some time ago I published a post on Don S. Shoemaker´s dominoes sets. These game sets were made in 2 different versions: the “tronco” (organic design box) and the boxed sliding lid models; the former also had a first series with a matching wood lid and the ones produced by George with a see-thru fiberglass lid.

This time I have to bring your attention to these wonderful Mexican handcraft dominoes sets made in ironwood (“palo fierro” for the locals) by the Seri natives in the northern state of Sonora, Mexico. The “palo fierro” handcrafts include boxes, sculptures, jewelry, etc., they are of a great artistic value and a source of income for this isolated community. So, I ask the help of all my readers to buy these look-alike dominoes sets and the other handicrafts directly from them and help also to stop the swindlers that are selling these dominoes sets as Don S. Shoemaker originals.

Take a close look at the differences between an authentic Don S. Shoemaker “tronco” dominoes box vs. the beautiful dominoes set interpretation from the Seri natives:

The Don S. Shoemaker “tronco” dominoes set:

  • Don never used ironwood (see box below)
  • The tile dots are made in silver, hollowed and sometimes engraved lines (see 2nd picture below)
  • The box always carries the decal studio label

The Seri natives dominoes sets handcraft:

  • They use ironwood for all their handicrafts
  • The tile dots are painted in white (see picture below)
  • You may also find a “deluxe model” with plain silver dots
  • You can also engrave the name of your brother, friend, etc. for a special gift (Mercado Libre “EBAY MEXICO” search palo fierro – see ad below)
  • It is important to know that I do not endorse any of the sites advertising these handcrafts. But the only way that I thought we could stop this new wave of alleged “Shoemaker dominoes sets” (that I have seen in galleries, auction houses and weekend flea markets going for $ 300 USD and more) is to buy directly from the producers of these sets knowing that we are not going to get a Shoemaker for $ 12 bucks but we are going to help the Seri natives in Sonora and they are going to be grateful.

Don is going to be proud of you guys because as you know, he was always involved in Charity programs.

Copyright © 2010-2017 Karin Goyer. All Rights Reserved.

@donshoemaker.com

Amazing similarity – QUIZ # 2

December 13, 2010

Karin Goyer Don S. Shoemaker Forgeries, Copies & Attributions , , 1 Comment


This time we are going to play the opposite game of the 7 differences. We are going to play the amazing similarities.

The rules are very simple:

  • Pay attention to the desk pictures and find as many mistakes made by the forger on the stripes which are identical on the pictures
  • Tip #1 : one mistake is when the wood stripe of the drawer is of a different color and wood than the frame wood and color
  • Another tip: the streak in wood is like a fingerprint, look for stripes of the same vein

Do not think these pictures come from the same place…..

  • One “After Don Shoemaker” desk picture comes from an auction announced for this December 14th
  • One picture comes from an attributed Don S. Shoemaker desk in a gallery
  • Two pictures come from a fake brand new 2009 production “Don Shoemaker desk” offered for sale in EBAY Mexico (MercadoLibre) some time ago. (read my post)

To give you a hint: 2 of the mistakes are on the drawers

So please let me know: how many mistakes did you find?

And your verdict based on the amazing similarities is:

  • guilty as charged – it is exactly the same desk
  • or it is an amazing coincidence that 3 desks have the same marks

By the way, this desk was also portrayed in an article published in “Interior Design” magazine

Copyright © 2010-2017 Karin Goyer. All Rights Reserved

@donshoemaker.com

Most underwhelming attribution to Don S. Shoemaker – part 9

October 27, 2010

Karin Goyer Don S. Shoemaker Forgeries, Copies & Attributions, George R. Shoemaker Heritage - ARRENDADORA SHOEMAKER , , Leave a comment


When attributing a piece of furniture to Don S. Shoemaker becomes grotesque:

-Who is to blame?

  • The consignor (particular? dealer?) that attributes a piece to a well-known designer, obviously with the hope of a good (profit? scamp?)
  • Furniture designs belonging to someone else, whose fine work in cueramo, cocobolo, granadilla, etc. are now being unscrupulously used with the purpose to deceive and shown in an auction catalog under Don S. Shoemaker´s name.
  • The auction house that clearly showed their ignorance or maybe it was greed? Or maybe they were acting in good faith? Finally it looks like a pretty grotesque scamp.
  • I saved this attributed dining room set including a rectangular table with 8 chairs and a matching cabinet (found at an auction) for a moment in which I think I am starting to solve the riddle involving attributions…
  • This set was produced using quality tropical woods, however, this model never existed during the SEÑAL, S.A. production days.
  • This dining room model was called “Silhouette”,  and it belonged to George R. Shoemaker design lines! The original ARRENDADORA SHOEMAKER studio label was removed to deceive.

Silhouette Cabinet designed by George R. Shoemaker by

The Silhoutte Dining Set designed by George R. Shoemaker

  • Always remember: if a furniture piece is produced in rosewood, granadilla or cocobolo make yourself a favor: do not think it is attributable to Don S. Shoemaker only for this reason!!!

Copyright © 2010-2017 Karin Goyer. All Rights Reserved

@donshoemaker.com



Most underwhelming attribution to Don S. Shoemaker – part 8

October 13, 2010

Karin Goyer Don S. Shoemaker Forgeries, Copies & Attributions , Leave a comment


I recently discovered this odd piece of furniture attributed to Don S. Shoemaker at an auction:

  • Described as a “Parsons” side table by Don S. Shoemaker….This forged “model” has been around for some time, I have already seen several versions at weekend flea markets in Mexico City. The original Don S. Shoemaker “Parsons line” has nothing in common with this unbecoming thing! Pitifully, the forger sacrificed various original Don S. Shoemaker service trays for the parquetry on the table top. Pay attention to the irregular cube sequence patched together and compare to an original service tray as Don used the “cube design” mainly on his boxes and trays. Also check the forged label that has been taped to the bottom of the table.

Copyright © 2010-2017 Karin Goyer. All Rights Reserved

@donshoemaker.com

AAD Appearances Are Deceptive…

September 30, 2010

Karin Goyer Don S. Shoemaker Forgeries, Copies & Attributions , , , , , , 3 Comments


Are you prepared to buy Don S. Shoemaker originals? Let´s make a quiz…

Appearances are deceptive. That´s why you must train your eye to find the differences between the originals, the copies and forgeries. It is like playing the cartoon of the 7 differences, but this time with the added value that you can save a lot of money with an accurate perception. This is the only weapon that we collectors have to fight forgers that are flooding the market taking advantage of our good faith.

Do not forget the MANTRA: if the piece seems odd,  if the leather is new, the wood looks new and smells like new, and carries no label or stamp or is taped, then it is a forgery or a brand new copy !

  • The Sling side table is part of the original “Sling Casuals Line” designed by Don S. Shoemaker in the 1960´s. I have included a picture of an original Sling side table from my personal collection and a picture of a brand new copy, as seen at an auction. The Sling side table was available either with a wooden top or a leather top.

Now, are you ready to identify which one is the original Sling side table and which one is the copy?

  • Another example for you to analyze. Which one is the original Don S. Shoemaker diamond desk and which one is the copy?

  • The Elephant Lounge chair: which one is the original Don S. Shoemaker Elephant Lounge chair and which one is the forgery?

  • This Game table is the last one in our quiz. Have you decided which one is the original and which one is the fake? One of them was found in a Mexican auction house and the other one in a Chicago based auction house.


Copyright © 2010-2017 Karin Goyer. All Rights Reserved

@donshoemaker.com

Older Entries

%d bloggers like this: